What to See & Do Where to Eat Where to Stay Info. Booth About Cooperstown Services & Businesses Membership
Where to Eat
"Hoffman House, Cooperstown, N.Y."
From the elegance of the Otesaga Resort Hotel to a picnic in the park Cooperstown has a wide variety of dining experiences to fit every budget and taste. Fresh local produce is served in many of our restaurants complimented by libations from our breweries, wineries and cider mills. You can even rent a boat and dine on the lake watching the sun set behind our beautiful unspoiled landscape.

All addresses listed are Cooperstown, NY  13326 unless otherwise noted.

Alex and Ika

149 Main Street - (607)547-4070

One of the "Top Ten Restaurants in NYS" Frommer's 2006. Visit us at alexandika.com.

American Hotel
PO Box 121, Sharon Springs, NY 13459-; Location: Main Street, Route 10 North, Sharon Springs, NY 13459 - (518)284-2105
"Highly Recommended" Fodor's 2007 Travel Guide

Black Cat Cafe & Bakery

PO Box 400, Sharon Springs, NY 13459; Location: 195 Main Street, Sharon Springs, NY 13459 - (518)284-2575

Café Bakery in historic Sharon Springs. Serving Breakfast & Lunch. Cakes, Parties, Weddings and Cooking Classes.

The Blue Mingo Grill
6098 St Hwy 80 - (607)547-7496

Christophers Restaurant & Country Lodge
4158 St Hwy 23, Oneonta, NY 13820; Location: St Hwy 28 Oneonta, NY  13820 - (607)432-2444

Clarion Hotel Oneonta
55 Market Street, Oneonta, NY 13820 - (607)432-7500
Exceptional accommodations for business or pleasure in the heart of historic downtown Oneonta, combining the luxuries and amenities of a new boutique style hotel and the quaint setting and convenience of a historic downtown Inn.

Cooley's Stone House Tavern
49 Pioneer Street - (607)544-1311

Cooperstown Diner
136 1/2 Main Street - (607)547-9201
Open 6am - 8pm everyday (Summer till 9pm). Serving breakfast till closing. Try our JUMBO burgers! Nightly Dinner Specials.

Cooperstown Farmers' Market/Otsego 2000
PO Box 1130; Location: 101 Main Street, Pioneer Alley - (607)547-8881

Depot Deli

21 Railroad Avenue - (607)547-7130

DiMaggios Cooperstown Hot Dog

4561 St Hwy 28, Milford, NY 13807 - (607)547-5400

A family restaurant serving regional style hotdogs, sandwiches, ice cream and real Italian Ices.

The Doubleday Café
93 Main Street - (607)547-5468

The Farmers' Museum
PO Box 30; Location: St Hwy 80 Lake Road - (607)547-1450

Fenimore Art Museum/NYSHA
PO Box 800; Location: St Hwy 80 Lake Road - (888)547-1450

Heidelberg Catering Services

2018 Genesee Street, Utica, NY 13502 - (315)732-6215

For more information about Heidelberg Catering Services and to see sample menus please visit our website at www.heidelbergcatering.com.

Hoffman Lane Bistro
2 Hoffman Lane - (607)547-7055

Holiday Inn of Oneonta/Cooperstown
5206 St Hwy 23, Oneonta, NY 13820 - (607)433-2250

Italian Kitchen
58-60 Market Street, Oneonta, NY 13820; Location: 66 Church Street, Oneonta, NY 13820 - (607)432-2776

Jackie's Restaurant
3688 St Hwy 28, Milford, NY 13807 - (607)286-7843

K-C's Corner Motel & Restaurant
5705 St Hwy 20, East Springfield, NY 13333 - (607)264-9392

La Tarantella

6181 St Hwy 7, Oneonta, NY 13820 - (607)432-1166

Ristorante and pizzeria offering authentic italian cuisine. Private room for large parties. Special menu available for catering - Let us deliver for your next party.

Lake Front Motel & Restaurant
10 Fair Street - (607)547-9511

Located in the village of Cooperstown on beautiful Otsego Lake, just one block from Baseball Hall of Fame.

The Lake House

2521 Co Rte 22, East Lake Road, Richfield Springs, NY 13439 - (315)858-2058

An historic inn and guest house dating from 1843 located on Canadarago Lake, about 12 miles north of Cooperstown. All rooms with private bath, hot breakfast also full service bar & restaurant on premises.

McDonald's of Cooperstown
4 Wells Street, Johnstown, NY 12095; Location: 60 Commons Drive, Cooperstown, NY 13326 - (607)547-1110

Nicoletta's Italian Cafe

96 Main Street - (607)547-7499

O'Hanlans Steakhouse

18 Commons Drive - (607)544-1401

The Otesaga Resort Hotel
PO Box 311; Location: 60 Lake Street, Route 80 - (800)348-6222

The Penguin

PO Box 104, Walton, NY 13856; 4833 St Hwy 28 - (607)267-6353

Pepper Mill

5418 St Hwy 28 - (607)547-8550

Just a step out of the village, enjoy our family steakhouse and banquet facilities.

Portabello's
6027 St Hwy 28, Fly Creek, NY 13337 - (607)547-5145

Portabello's, open 365 days a year, is your home away from home at the busy 4 corners in Fly Creek.

Remember When Cafe, Antiques and Guest House

34 North Main Street, New Berlin, NY  13411 - (607)847-9799

Stay in New Berlin's beautifully renovated old hospital, with victorian cafe and antique shop in the building. Outdoor dining available. Visit our website at www.rememberwhenguesthouse.com or email us rememberwhengh@frontiernet.net.

The Rose & Kettle

PO Box 73, Cherry Valley, NY 13320; Location: 4 Lancaster Street, Cherry Valley, NY  13320 - (607)264-3078

Fine dining in a two hundred year old house. Local and seasonal food. Chef-owned. Ten miles to Glimmerglass Opera.

Sabatini's Little Italy Restaurant & Villa
4158 St Hwy 23, Oneonta, NY 13820 - (607)432-3000

Sal's Pizzeria and Restaurant
110 Main Street - (607)547-5721

Stella Luna Ristorante'
58-60 Market Street, Oneonta, NY 13820 - (607)433-7646

Stewart's Shops
PO Box 435, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866; Location: 108 Chestnut Street - (607)547-7248

Tino's Pizza

75 Chestnut Street - (607)547-2930

Check out our daily lunch specials. Just a short distance from Main Street. It's well worth the walk! Homemade Italian-American specialties! Closed Sundays.

TJ's Place/The Home Plate

124 Main Street - (607)547-4040

Townsend Catering at Templeton Hall Banquet Facility
63 Pioneer Street - (607)547-8877
Templeton Hall banquet facility holds up to 125 people for functions including breakfast, lunch and dinner as well as meetings.

Triple Play Cafe

64 Main Street - (607)547-1395

The Tunnicliff Inn, Cooperstown
34 Pioneer Street - (607)547-9611
One minute's walk to the Baseball Hall of Fame, 498 feet away. In the center of downtown Cooperstown.

The Village Tower
17 Linden Avenue- (607)547-5570

Yum Yum Shack

4918 St Hwy 28 - (607)547-8088